I came to dinner with my husband and three kids ages 8, 10 and 12. The servers were very attentive. Our food was great. To be honest, this is the best meal we have had in East Hampton in the last 12 years. The foie gras tortellini was amazing. My kids shared a strip steak, they all enjoyed it. They also had the kids Mac and cheese which was great! We have the rigatoni bolognese and the tile fish which was so fresh and flaky. The smashed potatoes were delicious as well! We were so full we didn’t order dessert! Can’t wait to go back!

One of the most immaculate meals I’ve had. Thank you to our server, Jesse and the team there for making our date night so magical. I will definitely recommend this to everyone I know. The zucchini chips are a MUST!

It sounds expensive, looks exclusive and maybe "oh so fancy" but it's not. Instead it's a warm, inviting atmosphere with a friendly, unpretentious staff. I went in jeans and didn't feel out of place. Give this landmark a try just once, and you'll be a loyal regular too. PS: the background music is wonderful too!

We’ve visited Nick and Toni’s a few times, and we decided to return for my cousin’s birthday dinner this year. From the moment we made the reservation on Resy, where we noted the celebration, the staff went above and beyond to make the night truly special. They had the table beautifully set with birthday confetti and even created a gorgeous dessert plate to celebrate my cousin’s big day. The service was exceptional, as always—attentive, friendly, and professional. It’s always a fantastic experience, and we’re so grateful for the thoughtful touches that made this celebration unforgettable. Highly recommend!

This is what the Hamptons is all about! Loud, scenic, good service and delicious food! Is a big restaurant, but gets crowded, make a reservation

Enjoyed our 31st anniversary celebration at Nick & Tonis! The food and atmosphere never disappoint but the highlight of the evening was the service we received from their newest server Moses. He checked every box and went above and beyond to make sure we were well taken care of. His sincere concern for our needs was unsurpassed and Nick & Tonis is so very lucky to have him representing their incredible establishment. Thanks for an amazing experience Moses.... See you soon!

Visited for the 32 Two-Course Pizza & Pasta Prix Fixe. Excellent food. Excellent service (I suspect thanks to being off season). The wait staff coming to tell me the pasta special was SEVEN agnolotti not the SIX he had sold me, was a little over the top, but attention to detail is important

We were a group of three and had a great experience. We started with three appetizers: zucchini, artichokes and a salad. The first two were incredible. Then we shared a pizza and the rigatoni. Pizza was normal but the rigatoni...out of this world! Highly recommended. To end we had two desserts, the lemon tart and the ice cream. Finally, we also had an incredible wine, Lion Tamer, that’s a mix of Malbec and Cabernet.